Field Notes

Nine questions to ask before the numbers.

Your plan can be mathematically perfect and still fail, because the math is not the one who has to carry it out.

I have reviewed a lot of financial plans over twenty years. Good ones, bad ones, forty-page ones in leather binders. Very few of them failed on the math.

They failed in March 2009, when the person holding the plan sold everything. They failed when a brother-in-law made a killing on something and the plan suddenly looked boring. They failed quietly, when nobody could say what the money was actually for, so no amount ever felt like enough.

The plan was fine. Nobody had checked who was steering.

So I now ask nine questions before I ask for a single number. They take about a minute, and they are the first step of the free Napkin Plan.

Head: how you decide

Three questions about how a decision actually gets made in your house. For example: a big money decision lands on you. What is your first move? Do you write down what would have to be true, ask around until someone sounds sure, or wait until it decides itself?

None of those answers is shameful. But only one of them is steering.

Nerve: what fear does to your decisions

Three more. The blunt one: your investments are down 30%. What do you actually do? Not what you would tell a friend to do. What you do.

Fear is not a flaw. It is a fact, and denying it is how people get hurt. The whole point of my book is that fear can be taken apart into pieces small enough to act on. The Crisis Script is the piece for this one: you write the rule while the water is calm, so you are not inventing it in the storm.

A rule you wrote in calm beats a decision you make in panic. Every time.

Compass: what the money is for

The last three are the ones people skip, and they matter most. Do you have a number that means “enough”? If the money were handled tomorrow, what would you do with a Tuesday?

When someone cannot answer these, the plan has no destination, and a plan with no destination turns into a scoreboard. You keep climbing because climbing is the only instruction you have. Your Enough exists for exactly that.

What you get back

No score. No percentile. You are not being ranked against anyone, and I would not trust a quiz that claimed it could.

You get one plain line for each of the three: you’re steering, one hand on the wheel, or something else has the wheel. For the weakest answer in each, you get your own words read back to you and one small move for the week. That is it.

Then there is one optional sentence to finish: “The money is for…” Whatever you write becomes the first line of your napkin.

Why I put this before the math

Because the order matters. If I show you the numbers first, you will argue with the numbers. If you first notice that fear has been making your decisions, the numbers land differently. You stop asking “what should I buy” and start asking “what rule would have saved me last time.”

That second question is worth more than any stock pick I could give you, and I do not give stock picks.

The nine questions are the first step of the free Napkin Plan: a couple of minutes for the questions and the numbers together, no signup. All 21 systems from the book are free to read in the Field Manual.

One question to sit with this week: the last time you made a money decision you regret, who was steering?

Related questions: what to ask at your annual review, is my advisor doing a good job and financial advisor red flags.

As always, if you want to talk any of this through, the door is open. Genti

Reading is the easiest way in. The work happens in the conversation.

When you’re ready: get the free two-minute Napkin Plan, or book a 30-minute call.

Get my free Napkin Plan → Book a 30-min Call More Field Notes