Between retirement and the year RMDs start, most retirees sit in a tax-bracket valley nobody told them about: a window where converting some traditional IRA to Roth costs almost nothing and saves a fortune later. This Roth IRA conversion calculator shows the window, year by year.
Short answer
When should I do a Roth conversion?
Often in lower-income years before RMDs start, such as the gap between your last paycheck and required withdrawals. The idea: pay tax now in a lower bracket instead of later in a higher one. Conversions raise taxable income, which can raise Medicare premiums or shrink ACA subsidies, so plan the amount year by year.
| Year | Age | Suggested Conversion | Estimated Tax | Bracket Filled |
|---|
For most people who retire before their RMDs start (age 73, or 75 for anyone born in 1960 or later), there's a window of 5 to 15 years where their taxable income drops dramatically: they're no longer earning a paycheck, but they're not yet forced to take Required Minimum Distributions. The temptation is to enjoy the low-tax years. The smarter play is usually the opposite: convert traditional IRA dollars to Roth during this window, at low marginal rates, before RMDs force you back into a higher bracket.
Pay the tax now at 12%, or pay it later at 24%, possibly 32%, after RMDs and Social Security stack.
The math gets sharper once you account for IRMAA (Medicare surcharges that kick in at higher income), the ACA subsidy cliff before age 65, and the way Social Security taxation interacts with provisional income. The window has tradeoffs, but ignoring it usually costs more than running into them.
Most people never open the traditional IRA and price the tax sitting inside it. One look at the window turns that fog into a schedule.
Stopping work early often opens the low-bracket years this calculator is built to find.
It takes your age, traditional IRA balance, other retirement income, filing status and expected future bracket, then suggests a yearly conversion that fills the 12% bracket in each year before RMDs start. It compares that tax against converting later at your expected higher bracket, using 2026 federal brackets.
It tends to make sense when your income today sits in a lower bracket than you expect later, as it often does between your last paycheck and RMDs. The page frames it plainly: pay the tax now at 12%, or later at 24%, possibly 32%, once RMDs and Social Security stack.
This one says so openly: state tax, IRMAA Medicare surcharges, ACA subsidy effects before 65, Social Security taxation, and the 3.8% NIIT. Each can change the answer. A conversion raises MAGI, which can cost an ACA subsidy or trigger IRMAA. The calculator gets the bracket math right; a CPA or advisor covers the rest.
The calculator uses SECURE Act 2.0: age 75 for people born in 1960 or later, 73 for those born 1951 to 1959. The years between retirement and that age are the window, often 5 to 15 years, when income drops and converting can be cheap before RMDs push income back up.
If you're inside (or approaching) the window, this is a 30-minute conversation worth having.
Who I work with: founders, business owners and families who want one fee-only advisor for the whole picture. Investment management is 1% a year on the first $1 million, lower above that; ongoing planning with investment management is $7,500 a year, or the asset-based fee if higher. Not ready for that? The Starter Plan is a one-time plan from $1,500.
Set your numbers and the napkin writes itself. Download it, share it, tape it to the fridge. Numbers argue better when they're drawn.
One essay a month on money and the decisions behind it. No fluff, no upsells.
One per month. Unsubscribe with one click.